Good afternoon

Our earlier bulletin reported successful Supported Housing Benefit appeals brought on behalf of Choice Housing tenants, after Sheffield City Council suspended and cancelled existing awards and refused new claims. That bulletin attracted more than 1,000 LinkedIn impressions. We have now received Judge Mettam’s full Statement of Reasons, addressing both the Council’s decision-making and the substantive question of whether Choice Housing provided more than minimal care, support or supervision.

The written reasons are comprehensive. They confirm not only that the tenants succeeded on the merits (the more-than-minimal test), but also that the Council failed to establish a lawful basis to disturb existing Housing Benefit awards.

The Council did not establish a lawful route to change the awards

The Judge found that the Council’s cancellation notices did not identify an effective date, the statutory power being used or the reasons for the decisions. Because the original awards were final, they could be changed only by revision or supersession under the Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit (Decisions and Appeals) Regulations 2001. The Council had to justify the route it relied on, and it failed to discharge that burden, just as we had stated at the outset.

As our skeleton argument stated, the starting point was important. The Council had originally accepted over 11 years that the tenants occupied supported exempt accommodation (SEA) and received more than minimal care, support or supervision. It did not produce the evidence on which it made those awards. The Tribunal therefore proceeded on the basis that it had fully accepted the qualifying conditions at the time. The Council then had to show either that the original decisions were wrong from the outset or that a relevant change of circumstances had occurred. It proved neither.

No basis for supersession or revision

The Tribunal rejected the suggestion that later production or closer examination of evidence itself constituted a change of circumstances. Nor did government-funded scrutiny initiatives, guidance, or the Supported Housing (Regulatory Oversight) Act 2023 alter the established legal test or create a gateway for supersession.

The alternative revision case also failed. The Council argued that the original awards were made in ignorance of, or based on a mistake about, the nature and level of support. However, it produced no contemporaneous material showing what, supposedly, had been misunderstood. The latter case note evidence was relevant to the circumstances at the time the original awards were made and, in the Judge’s assessment, confirmed that more than minimal support was provided throughout.

The merits: a holistic and cumulative assessment

On the substantive issue, the Judge found that every appellant required and received care, support or supervision that was significantly more than minimal. She rejected the Council’s method of isolating individual activities and excluding each one in turn. The correct approach was to consider the evidence holistically and cumulatively, in the context of each tenant’s needs and Choice Housing’s overall support model.

The Tribunal placed significant weight on independent referrals (e.g. neighbouring councils, the Salvation Army, other charitable bodies), needs assessments, occupancy agreements, case notes, medical evidence, Care Act assessments, and oral evidence.

It accepted that earlier record-keeping had been inadequate, but rejected the suggestion that later, fuller records had been concocted or edited to strengthen the appeals. The improvement reflected Choice Housing’s developing understanding of the much more detailed evidence the Council had begun to demand.

The Judge found Mr Mellors to be a credible and reliable witness with detailed personal knowledge of the tenants and their circumstances. The absence of a note recording every informal interaction did not undermine that evidence. The Judge also drew no adverse inference from the appellants’ or support workers’ failure to give live evidence.

The support went well beyond ordinary housing management. It included encouraging engagement with health and substance-misuse services; intervening in disputes, antisocial behaviour, theft and coercion; arranging food-bank support; helping with benefits, budgeting and access to DWP systems; and monitoring rooms and living conditions for signs of declining health, disengagement or increased substance misuse. Choice Housing was not required to provide a “gold standard” service or secure a successful outcome from every intervention.

What happens next?

Sheffield City Council is currently considering whether it should seek permission to appeal. However, any appeal to the Upper Tribunal would have to identify an arguable material error of law; it would not simply allow a re-run of the factual case or invite a different view of the evidence. The Upper Tribunal exercises an error-of-law jurisdiction and generally does not interfere merely because another tribunal might have approached the facts differently.

That does not make an appeal impossible, and it would be premature to predict the Council’s position. However, the breadth and detail of Judge Mettam’s reasons would present a substantial obstacle. She addressed the statutory gateways, identified the evidential burden, explained why the Council’s revision and supersession arguments failed, assessed the evidence in detail and made clear findings on credibility, individual need and level of support provided.

For Choice Housing and the affected tenants, the Statement of Reasons therefore provides a strong and carefully reasoned confirmation of the result already reported. It also offers wider lessons for councils and supported housing providers: councils cannot displace existing awards without a lawful decision-making gateway, and they must assess support in the round rather than try to reduce it to a series of isolated interventions.

Bill Irvine

UC Advice & Advocacy Ltd

www.ucadvice.co.uk

Tel: 07733 080 389